Board Seats For Sale?

Total SelloutOut of the dead of night with no recent board debate or member input, newly elected PEC Director Paul Graff has prepared a resolution which, if passed TOMORROW, will enable qualified candidates for the PEC board to acquire the names and addresses of PEC members who voted in recent elections.  This resolution, peddled as seemingly innocent, is nothing more than a sellout to high powered political operatives and special interests chomping at the bit to buy PEC board seats for pennies on the dollar.

If this resolution passes, it will mark a turning point in the history of PEC and a retreat for the hard-earned reforms fought for by PEC member-owners.

If passed, candidates in future elections will not need to bother campaigning at large or within their districts for votes. All they’ll need to do is secure the 20,000  names of the  voting members and target just them with direct mail. (Over 200,000 of our members choose not to vote for one reason or another). Direct mail and other marketing tools will be used not only to extol a candidate’s virtues but to smear their opponents.

The same filthy money-slime that permeates American politics today, with control going to those with the deepest pockets, is about to arrive at PEC. Forget the quaint notion that any member can run for a board seat. In the future, only those with ACCESS to deep pocket influence peddlers (customer choice interests, private vendors who seek to do business with PEC, oil, coal & gas or, renewable energy interests…the list is endless) will have a chance.

When members truly understand the ramifications about what may happen, they’ll be outraged. At a minimum, this matter should have a full public hearing and a directive to send it to a member referendum for a vote.

Here is that resolution which is coming before the board TOMORROW, January 19, 2016:

Proposed Amendment to PEC Elections Policy & Procedures Relating to Voter History Information (Add new Section 7.12.1) Candidates Access to Voting History. After a Candidate has been duly qualified and approved to be listed on the ballot, the Candidate may request and be provided a Voter History List that contains only the names and mailing addresses of Members who voted in the election immediately preceding the current Election (i.e., email address and/or telephone number and other personal information is not to be provided). The Voter History List shall not contain any information that could indicate or otherwise reveal any selections made by the Member in the election (for example, for whom the Member voted or how the Member voted on any question). To obtain the Voter History List, a Candidate must request this information by contacting the PEC Election Liaison. The candidate must affirm in a sworn, notarized affidavit to use the list only as directly related to the PEC Board of Directors election and for no other purpose. 

Passage of this resolution would constitute an invasion of privacy to our members (do our members really want their names identified as having voted in their cooperative’s elections? Do our member-voters really want to be targeted and inundated by marketers hired by candidates seeking a seat on the PEC board?  Do our members wish to see board seats bought and paid for “on the cheap” by outside political interests ? Do members who choose not to vote wish for all time to be ignored and invisible to candidates running for board seats?Greed

Director Graff is apparently doing the bidding of the Board President who attempted to pass a similar resolution a year ago and lost. Now in the driver’s seat and determined to show who’s boss, Oakley has apparently enlisted Graff to carry the water this time. It is Graff who will now own this loser.

I hope that board members are not so cynical. I am always hopeful that reason will prevail and that good people will do the right thing–that a profile in courage will emerge. In this case the right thing for the Board is to protect the members they were elected to serve and to keep the PEC board as far away from conventional politics as they can.

Stay tuned.



2 thoughts on “Board Seats For Sale?

  1. Tell me this didn’t pass. Please!

    Sounds like they’re taking a page right out of the playbook of CoServ, a coop-in-name-only in the Dallas area. They played the same game to keep their chosen board members installed. One board member sued them over it and other malfeasance shortly after we took on Bennie and Bud at PEC, but I believe CoServ’s lawyers and deep pockets out-gunned his financial backing. He also wasn’t able to get much traction from the members, news media, or legislature, so there wasn’t the publicity.

    I certainly hope that the current PEC board has the sense to see that this will cause a feedback loop – those who vote get all the attention from the deep pocketed players, who then have a better chance of getting elected. Then the same players repeat, and as you point out, the “any member” candidates don’t stand a chance after a few rounds.

    It’s not as bad as the Bennie/Bud power play of having the sitting members appoint the nomination committee and the nomination committee nominate the sitting members (or hand picked replacements) with no chance of anyone outside the good ol boys club getting nominated, much less elected. But it still tips the balance of power enough to qualify as a move away from democratic rule.

    Board members – and I know you read this – please shoot this idea down.


    • I am afraid it did pass. Those voting in favor: Oakley, Pataki, Graff and Akers. Opposed: Clement, Scanlon and Perry. It was shoved through with little debate and certainly without formalized public comments. I will have more to say on this soon. Thank you for your comments…


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s